Poshmark vs Depop vs eBay: Which Platform is Right for You?

If you have ever cleaned out your closet or thrifted with the intention to resell, you have probably wondered which platform is actually worth your time. Poshmark, Depop, and eBay are some of the most popular options out there, but they each have their pros and cons. I am breaking down what you need to know about each one so you can pick the best fit for your stuff and your style of selling.

Item Types

Poshmark is mostly geared toward clothing, shoes, and accessories. It started out as a place for trendy, gently used fashion and it still has that vibe. You can also list home goods now but fashion is really where it shines.

Depop leans younger and more alternative. Think Y2K, vintage, streetwear, handmade pieces, and anything that is a little more unique. If your item would appeal to a more creative crowd, Depop could be a good match.

eBay is the most flexible. You can list pretty much anything from clothes to collectibles to electronics. If you are looking to sell a variety of things or something that does not fit the fashion niche, eBay gives you that freedom.

Fees

Poshmark takes a flat 20 percent fee on sales over fifteen dollars. For items under fifteen dollars, you pay a flat two ninety five. It is simple and there are no listing fees.

Depop takes ten percent plus transaction fees from PayPal or Depop Payments. So overall you are looking at closer to thirteen percent or so depending on the payment method.

eBay has a more layered fee structure. You will pay around twelve to fifteen percent depending on category plus possible PayPal fees if you are not on eBay Payments. There can also be listing fees after a certain number of free listings per month.

Audience

Poshmark buyers tend to be looking for mall brands, popular labels, and easy to wear pieces. It is a great space if you are reselling things like Madewell, Anthropologie, or athletic wear.

Depop’s audience skews younger. A lot of buyers are looking for something different or nostalgic. If you are listing oversized hoodies, graphic tees, or handmade jewelry, Depop has that built-in fan base.

eBay has a massive and broad audience. People shop there for everything. It is a great choice for niche items or things that might not fit the vibe of Poshmark or Depop.

Ease of Use

Poshmark is super easy to list on. The app guides you through the process and offers prepaid labels so shipping is really simple.

Depop is also easy to list on but you will have to figure out shipping on your own unless you use their shipping service. The interface is clean and very visual which is fun if you like curating your shop.

eBay can feel more overwhelming because of all the options. There are more boxes to check and more decisions to make but once you get used to it, it is not too bad.

So Which One Should You Pick?

If you want easy shipping, fashion focus, and a straightforward fee structure, Poshmark is probably the way to go.
If you are selling vintage, streetwear, or creative pieces, Depop’s audience is a good fit.
If you have a wide mix of items or something unique, eBay gives you the biggest reach.

Honestly, you can always try more than one and see what works for you. Each platform has its strengths and it often comes down to what you are selling and how you like to run your shop.

Final Thoughts

At the end of the day, the best platform is the one that matches your items and your selling style. Hopefully this breakdown helps you decide where to start.